Skip to product information
1 of 5


New York Baseball Fan Cookie Stencil Set

New York Baseball Fan Cookie Stencil Set

Regular price $11.99 USD
Regular price Sale price $11.99 USD
Sale Sold out

View full details

About this item

Go into the 7th inning stretch with cookies decorated with our NY Yankees inspired cookie stencil set. Great for baseball themed parties! Use with 3 and 4-inch cookie cutters, or even better, use with the matching cookie cutters. Pinstripes forever!

Pair with other baseball cookie stencils. and baseball cookie cutters



  • NY w/ Hat: 2 3/4" h x 2 6/8" w 
  • NY heartbeat: 1 3/4" h x 3 1/4" w
  • NYY w/ ball: 3" h x 2 3/4" w 
  • Stencil Sheet is 5 1/2" square (minus the tab) and fits nicely inside a Stencil Genie.

Cookie Cutters:

  • NY w/ Hat: 3 1/4" h x 3 1/8" w 
  • NY heartbeat: 2 1/2 " h x 4 1/2" w
  • NYY w/ ball: 3 1/2" h x 3 1/2"

Customizing Your Stencil:

  • Contact us today or start a chat conversation with us if you need these in a different size, want more overlays, or want to personalize these baseball stencils for a birthday or wedding.
  • To create your own cookie stencil messages for this baseball cookie stencil set, click here.

Stencil and Cookie Cutter Highlights & Care:

  • Stencils are Laser cut on 10 mil food-grade Mylar
  • Cutters are 3D printed on site in the USA
  • Stencils work well with both royal icing and airbrushing
  • Stencils and Cookie Cutters are Made in the USA
  • DO NOT HEAT THE STENCILS OR CUTTERS!  - to clean, gently clean under warm soapy water and allow to airdry. You can even clean them between two damp paper towels.
  • Stencil Storage: Store stencils in our Keep Safe Album to prevent damage.

Cool Stenciling Tools and Tips to Use With This Stencil:

  • Works best when stenciled onto cookies made with the accompanying cookie cutters.
  • Airbrushing? Pair your airbrush with the Screen Genie to keep underspray at bay, and to reveal crisp reveals on your iced cookies. Make sure to use Airbrush Colorants in navy blue to follow along with the theme!
  • Applying this stencil with royal icing? Scrape with our stencil scraper or the Icing Genie using navy blue!